Información del artículo
Resumen
En este artículo se estudian las teorías del valor, del crecimiento y del empresario de tres importantes autores, David Hume, Adam Smith y Jeremy Bentham. Se demuestra que el utilitarismo y las distintas teorías del tiempo son la base de las diferencias de estas concepciones, que incluso tienen distintos “protagonistas”. Los tres autores son innovadores en teoría económica y sus obras pueden considerarse paradigmas de tres distintos modelos económicos.
Palabras clave:
Teorías del Valor
Teoría del Empresario
Crecimiento Económico
Utilitarismo
Abstract
This article studies the theories of value, economic growth and entrepreneurship of three relevant authors, David Hume, Adam Smith and Jeremy Bentham. Utilitarianism and their different conceptions of time are the basis for different theories, which are even represented by different main characters. The three economic theories are original and theoretically innovative and we may use them as three different economic models.
Key words:
Theory of Value
Entrepreneurship
Economic Growth
Utilitarianism
El Texto completo está disponible en PDF
Bibliografía
[Árdal, 1966]
Pall S. Árdal.
Passion and Value in Hume's Treatise.
University of Edinburgh Press, (1966),
[Bentham, 1981]
Jeremy Bentham.
Tratados de legislación civil y penal.
Editora Nacional, (1981),
[Black, 1988]
Collinson R.D. Black.
Bentham and the Political Economists of the Nineteenth Century.
The Bentham Newsletter, 12 (1988), pp. 24-36
[Blaug, 1959]
Mark Blaug.
Welfare indices in the Wealth of Nations.
The Southern Economic Journal, 26 (1959), pp. 150-153
[Bonner, 1995]
John Bonner.
Economic Efficiency and Social Justice: The Development of Utilitarian Ideas in Economics from Bentham to Edgeworth.
Edward Elgar, (1995),
[Cabrillo, 1991]
Francisco Cabrillo.
Lecturas de Economía Política.
Minerva Ediciones, (1991),
[Cantillon, 1950]
Richard Cantillon.
Ensayo sobre la naturaleza del comercio en general.
FCE, (1950),
[Castán, 1987]
José Castán.
Reus, (1987),
[Das Gupta, 1960]
Ajit Kumar Das Gupta.
Adam Smith on value.
Indian Economic Review, 5 (1960), pp. 105-115
[Davidson, 1976]
Donald Davidson.
Hume's Cognitive Theory of Pride.
The Journal of Philosophy, 73 (1976), pp. 744-757
[Diaye and Lapidus, 2005]
Marc-Arthur Diaye, André Lapidus.
A Humean Theory of Choice of which rationality may be one consequence.
European Journal of History of Economic Thought, 12 (2005), pp. 89-101
[Dube, 1991]
Allison Dube.
The Theme of Acquisitiveness in Bentham‘s political thought.
Garland publishing, (1991),
[Ekelund et al., 1992]
Robert B. Ekelund, Robert F. Hébert.
Historia de la teoría económica y de su método.
McGraw-Hill, (1992),
[Evensky, 2005]
Jerry Evensky.
Adam Smith's Moral Philosophy: A Historical and Contemporary Perspective on Markets, Law, Ethics and Culture.
Cambridge University Press, (2005),
[Fleischacker, 2004]
Samuel Fleischacker.
On Adam Smith's Wealth of nations: A philosophical companion.
Princeton University Press, (2004),
[Garrett, 1997]
Don Garrett.
Cognition and Commitment in Hume's Philosophy.
Oxford University Press, (1997),
[Griswold, 1999]
Charles Griswold Jr..
Adam Smith and the Virtues of Enlightenment.
Cambridge University Press, (1999),
[Groenewegen, 1977]
Peter Groenewegen.
Adam Smith and the Division of Labour: A Bicentenary Estimate.
Australian Economic Papers, (1977), pp. 161-174
[Haakonssen, 1995]
Knud Haakonssen.
The Science of a Legislator.
Cambridge University Press, (1995),
[Harris, 1983]
Marvin Harris.
Introducción a la antropología general.
Alianza, (1983),
[Hébert and Link, 1988]
Robert F. Hébert, Albert N. Link.
The Entrepreneur. Mainstream Views and Radical Critics.
2ª edición, Praeger, (1988),
[Hébert and Link, 2006]
Robert F. Hébert, Albert N. Link.
The Entrepreneur as innovator.
Journal of Technology Transfer, 31 (2006), pp. 589-597
[Heberton, 1949]
Heberton, Evans Jr, G. (1949): “The entrepreneur and economic theory, a historical and analytical approach” The American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, XXXIX, pp.337–38.
[Henderson, 1954]
John P. Henderson.
The Macro and Micro Aspects of the Wealth of Nations.
The Southern Economic Journal, 21 (1954), pp. 25-35
[Hollander, 1973]
Samuel Hollander.
The economics of Adam Smith.
Heinemann Educational Books, (1973),
[David, 1964a]
David Hume.
Scientia Verlag, (1964),
[Hume, 1964b]
David Hume.
Scientia Verlag, (1964),
[Hume, 1964c]
David Hume.
Scientia Verlag Aalen, (1964),
[Hume, 1964c]
David Hume.
Orbis, (1986),
[Hutchison, 1976]
Terence W. Hutchison.
The Bicentenary of Adam Smith.
Economic Journal, 86 (1976), pp. 481-492
[Ippolito, 1977]
Richard A. Ippolito.
The Division of Labour in the Firm.
Economic Inquiry, 15 (1977), pp. 469-492
[Jevons, 1998]
William Stanley Jevons.
La Teoría de la Economía Política.
Pirámide, (1998),
[Kauder, 1953]
Emil Kauder.
Genesis of the Marginal Utility Theory.
Economic Journal, 63 (1953), pp. 638-650
[Keynes, 1925]
John Maynard Keynes.
Alfred Marshall.
Memorials of Alfred Marshall,
[Khan, 1954]
Mustaq S. Khan.
Adam Smiths Theory of Economic Development in Relation to underdeveloped Economies.
Indian Journal of Economics, Vol. 34 (1954), pp. 337-342
[Kieerkegard, 1965]
Soren Kieerkegard.
Obras y papeles de S. Kierkegaard.
Guadarrama, (1965),
[Knight, 1947]
Frank H. Knight.
Riesgo Incertidumbre y Beneficio.
Aguilar, (1947),
[Lapidus and Sigot, 2000]
André Lapidus, Nathalie Sigot.
Individual utility in a context of asymmetric sensitivity to pleasure and pa an interpretation of Bentham's felicific calculus.
European Journal for the History of Economic Thought, 7 (2000), pp. 45-78
[Levy, 1999]
David M. Levy.
Adam Smith‘s Katallactic model of gambling: approbation from the spectator.
Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 21 (1999), pp. 81-91
[Marshall, 1998]
Mike G. Marshall.
Scottish Economic Thought and the High Wage Economy: Hume, Smith and McCulloch on Wages and Work Motivation.
Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 45 (1998), pp. 309-328
[Menudo et al., 2006]
MENUDO, José María y O’KEAN, José María, (2006): “The French Tradition: an Alternative Theoretical Framework”, Working papers series, WP ECON 06.24, Department of Economics, UPO.
[Mill, 1978]
John Stuart Mill.
Principios de Economía Política.
FCE, (1978),
[Mitchell, 1918]
Wesley C. Mitchell.
Bentham's Felicific Calculus.
Political Science Quarterly, 33 (1918), pp. 161-183
[Montes, 2004]
Leonidas Montes.
Adam Smith in Context: A Critical Reassessment of Some Central Components of His Thought.
Palgrave Macmillan, (2004),
[Murphy, 1984]
Francis Ysidro Edgeworth.
Economists and the Irish Economy. From the 18th century to the present,
[O'Brien, 1989]
Denis P. O'Brien.
Los economistas clásicos.
Alianza, (1989),
[Pesciarelli, 1989]
Enzo Pesciarelli.
Smith, Bentham and the development of contrasting ideas on entrepreneurship.
History of Political Economy, 21 (1989), pp. 521-536
[Pownall, 1776]
Pownall.
A letter from Governor Pownall to Adam Smith”, Apéndice A.
The Correspondence of Adam Smith,
[Ricardo, 1966]
David Ricardo.
The University Press for the Royal Economic Society, (1966),
[Robbins, 1953]
Lionel C. Robbins.
The Theory of Economic Policy in English Classical Political Economy.
MacMillan, (1953),
[Roncaglia, 1997]
Alessandro Roncaglia.
Reseña del libro de John Bonner, Economic Efficiency and Social Justice.
Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 19 (1997), pp. p319
[Rosenberg, 1965]
Nathan Rosenberg.
Adam Smith on the Division of Labour: Two Views or One.
Economica, 32 (1965), pp. 127-139
[Rosenberg, 1976]
Nathan Rosenberg.
Another Advantage of the Division of Labour.
Journal of Political Economy, 84 (1976), pp. 861-868
[Ross Simpson, 1995]
Ian Simpson Ross.
The Life of Adam Smith.
Clarendon Press, (1995),
[Santos, 1997]
Manuel Santos.
Los economistas y la empresa. Empresa y empresario en la historia del pensamiento económico.
Alianza, (1997),
[Schumpeter, 1954]
Joseph A. Schumpeter.
History of Economic Analysis.
OUP, (1954),
[Schumpeter, 1949]
Joseph A. Schumpeter.
Change and the entrepreneur.
Harvard University, (1949),
[Schumpeter, 1966]
Joseph A. Schumpeter.
La teoría económica y la historia empresarial” (1949).
Ensayos, Oikos-Tau, (1966),
[SCHWARTZ and Pedro, 1996]
Pedro Schwartz.
¿Importan los hechos para los juicios morales? Una defensa contra la navaja de Hume basada en la noción de coste de oportunidad.
Télos, 2 (1996), pp. 87-113
[Smith, 1976]
Adam Smith.
An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations.
Oxford University Press (WN), (1976),
[Smith, 1978]
Adam Smith.
Lectures on Jurisprudence.
Oxford University Press, (1978),
[Smith, 1980]
Adam Smith.
Essays on Philosophical Subjects.
Oxford University Press, (1980),
[Smith, 1985]
Adam Smith.
Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres.
Liberty Fund, (1985),
[Smith, 1987]
Adam Smith.
The Correspondence of Adam Smith.
OUP, (1987),
[Smith, 1994]
Adam Smith.
La riqueza de las Naciones.
Alianza, (1994),
[Smith, 1997]
Adam Smith.
La Teoría de los Sentimientos Morales.
Alianza, (1997),
[Spengler, 1975]
Joseph J. Spengler.
Adam Smith and society‘s decision-makers.
Essays on Adam Smith, pp. 397-400
[Stark, 1952a]
Werner Stark.
The Royal Economic Society, (1952),
[Stark, 1952b]
Werner Stark.
The Royal Economic Society, (1952),
[Stark, 1954]
Werner Stark.
The Royal Economic Society, (1954),
[Stewart, 1977]
John B. Stewart.
The Moral and Political Philosophy of David Hume.
Grenwood Press Publishers, (1977),
[Sugden, 1991]
Robert Sugden.
Rational choice: a survey of contributions from economics and philosophy.
Economic Journal, 101 (1991), pp. 751-785
[Trincado, 2003a]
Estrella Trincado.
Crítica a la doctrina de la Utilidad y Revisión de las teorías de Hume Smith y Bentham.
E-PrintsUCM, (2003),
[Trincado, 2003b]
Estrella Trincado.
Adam Smith: crítico del utilitarismo.
Télos. Revista Iberoamericana de Estudios Utilitaristas, XII (2003), pp. 43-62
[Trincado, 2004]
Estrella Trincado.
Bentham. Precursor de los Austríacos.
Procesos de Mercado. Revista Europea de Economía Política, 2 (2004), pp. 119-149
[Trincado, 2005]
Estrella Trincado.
Utility, Money and transaction costs: Authoritarian vs libertarian monetary policies.
History of Economic Ideas, XIII (2005), pp. 57-77
[Trincado, 2006]
Estrella Trincado.
Adam Smith criticism of the doctrine of utility: a theory of the Creative Present.
New Voices on Adam Smith, pp. 313-327
[Trincado, 2008]
Trincado Estrella Estudio preliminar Ensayos Morales y Literarios de David Hume, Madrid Tecnos 2008
[Tuttle, 1927]
Charles A. Tuttle.
The entrepreneur function in economic literature.
Journal of Political Economy, (1927), pp. 504-505
[Urrutia, 1983]
Juan Urrutia.
Economía Neoclásica.
Pirámide, (1983),
[Valdaliso and Lopez, 2007]
Jesús María Valdaliso, Santiago López.
Historia económica de la empresa.
Editorial Crítica, (2007),
[Vivenza, 2001]
Gloria Vivenza.
Adam Smith and Classics. The Classical Heritage in Adam Smith's thought.
Oxford University Press, (2001),
[Young, 1995]
Jeffrey T. Young.
Natural Jurisprudence and the Theory of Value in Adam Smith.
History of Political Economy, 27 (1995), pp. 755-773
Copyright © 2009. Asociación Española de Historia Económica