The marine biota from the middle Pennsylvanian outcrops of the Sierra Agua Verde, located in mid-eastern Sonora, consists of phylloid algae of the genera Komia and Eugonophyllum and a number of invertebrates. These species include bioaccumulations of chaetetids; brachiopods of the genera Dielasma sp., Reticulariina sp., Anthracospirifer sp., Antiquatonia sp.; bryozoans of the genus Thamniscus; tabulate corals such as Syringopora and solitary corals such as Zaphrentis; fusulinid foraminifera such as Pseudostaffella, Eoshubertella texana, Fusulinella llanoensis, and Zellerella; gastropods of the genus Euomphalus and Donaldina; and the crinoid genera Cyclocaudex, Cyclocrista, Heterosteleschus, Lamprosterigma, Mooreanteris, Pentagonopternix, Preptopremium, Cycloscaspus, and Pentaridica. The material was collected from outcrops in the first 512m of the La Joya Formation, and their sediments have a total thickness of 780m and consist of limestone interbedded with calcareous mudstone and sandstone lenses. The age of the middle Pennsylvanian strata corresponds to that of the Atokan stage (311 million years). The species assemblages are typical of a shallow tropical marine benthos. The analysis of the distribution of the species allowed for the determination of their paleogeographic relationships with the components of the biota of the Carboniferous strata of Texas and Kansas in the United States of America, which belong to the province of the North American Craton.
La biota marina procedente de afloramientos del Pensilvánico medio de la sierra Agua Verde localizada en la región centro este de Sonora, está conformada por algas filoides de los géneros Komia y Eugonophyllum,por numerosos invertebrados entre ellos bioacumulaciones de chaetétidos, braquiópodos de los géneros: Dielasma sp., Reticulariina sp., Anthracospirifer sp., Antiquatonia sp., briozoarios fenestélidos del género Thamniscus, corales tabulados como Syringopora y solitarios como Zaphrentis, foraminíferos-fusulínidos entre ellos Pseudostaffella, Eoshubertella, Fusulinella, Zellerella, gasterópodos de los géneros Euomphalus y Donaldina, y numerosos géneros de crinoideos Cyclocaudex, Cyclocrista, Heterosteleschus, Lamprosterigma, Mooreanteris, Pentagonopternix, Preptopremium, Cycloscaspus, Pentaridica. El material fue recolectado en afloramientos de los primeros 512m de la formación La Joya, cuyos sedimentos tienen un espesor total de 780m y están formados por caliza intercalada con lodolita calcárea y lentes de arenisca. La edad de los estratos corresponde al Pensilvánico Medio (Atokano) con una antigüedad de 311 millones de años. La tanatocenosis es típica del bentos de mares tropicales someros. El análisis de la distribución de las especies permitió establecer relaciones paleogeográficas con componentes de la biota del Carbonífero de Texas y Kansas en los Estados Unidos de Norteamérica, pertenecientes a la provincia del Cratón Norteamericano.
The Paleozoic rocks of Sonora consist of carbonate rocks from a warm, shallow marine environment. These rocks are believed to be between approximately 250 and 540 million years old and contain a diverse biota composed of phylloid algae, fusulinid foraminifera, sclerosponges, corals, bryozoans, brachiopods, and crinoids. Relatively few studies of the Pennsylvanian inner shelf of the Sierra Agua Verde have been conducted (Peiffer, Echevarría, Salas, & Rangin, 1980). Previous research includes the publications of Almazán-Vázquez, Buitrón-Sánchez, Vachard, Mendoza-Madera, and Gómez-Espinosa (2007); Buitrón-Sánchez, Almazán-Vázquez, Vachard, and Gómez-Espinosa (2006); Buitrón-Sánchez, Gómez-Espinosa, Almazán-Vázquez, and Vachard (2007); Mendoza-Madera, Almazán-Vázquez, Buitrón-Sánchez, and Vachard (2004); Stewart, Madrid, Poole, and Kernet (1988); Stewart, Poole, and Roldán (1990) and Stewart et al. (1999). The abundance and variety of the biota have been the subjects of paleontological study (Gómez-Espinosa, 2010; Ochoa-Camarillo & Sosa-León, 1993).
The State of Sonora is located in northwest Mexico and is bordered on the north by the United States of America, on the east by the State of Chihuahua, on the south by the State of Sinaloa, and on the west by the Gulf of California and the State of Baja California. The state's geographic coordinates are latitude 32°29′ N, 26°17′ S; longitude 108°25′ E, 115°03′ W (Fig. 1). The Sierra Agua Verde falls within the following coordinates: latitude 29°19′ N and longitude 109°56′ W, latitude 29°19′ N and longitude 109°49′ W, latitude 29°10′ N and longitude 109°55′ W, and latitude 29°10′ N and longitude 109°46′ W. The area is located 110km north-east of the state capital of Hermosillo (Fig. 1).
Location of the Sierra Agua Verde (Almazán-Vázquez et al., 2007).
The geology of the Paleozoic era in the mid-eastern region of Sonora is characterized by a calcareous platform and basinal siliciclastic deposits (Ochoa-Camarillo & Sosa-León, 1993) spanning the interval from the Cambrian to the Permian (Stewart, & Poole, 2002). The fossil biota comes from the limestone and shale of the La Joya formation, found in the outcrops of La Joya and Agua Caliente that form parts of the Sierra Agua Verde, which have thicknesses of approximately 294 and 780m, respectively. The lower contact of the bed is contiguous with the Santiago formation, and the upper contact is formed by a normal fault with the Tuntunudé formation. The base of this formation mainly consists of fossiliferous limestone in thick to medium strata, sandstone, mudstone, and lenses of sandstone and chert. Limestone is found throughout the entire sequence but occurs mainly in its lower portion, where it is light gray to reddish-brown color and forms medium-to-thick bands to massive levels with thin layers of interbedded calcareous mudstone. The limestone also features black and red chert nodules on its weathered surface and gray chert nodules on its fresh surface. The stratification of the limestone is gradual. At the sequence's base, it ranges from thick to massive strata with chert nodules and lenses. This portion of the sequence can be seen in the western foothills of La Joya. Next, there is a block of limestone, light gray on its unexposed surface and blue-gray on its weathered surface, which contains interbedded calcareous mudstone of a reddish color in strata of up to 3m in thickness, with small quartz crystals occurring in the mudstone. Present in both the limestone and the mudstone are tabulate corals of the genus Syringopora and numerous plates and columnar fragments of crinoids of the genera Pentaridica, Pentagonopternix, Cyclocaudex, Mooreanteris, Lamprosterigma, Cyclocrista, Preptopremnum, Heterosteleschus, and Cycloscapus, as well as the shell remnants of gastropods and fenestellid bryozoan colonies. The upper part of the sequence consists of limestone strata of medium thickness, interbedded with calcareous mudstones, nodular chert, and lenses. The limestone is a light gray to reddish-brown color on its weathered surface and a light to dark gray on its fresh surface, the mudstone is a reddish-brown color, and on both the weathered and fresh surfaces, the nodular chert and lenses are white to reddish-brown with small bands of dark color; sandstone lenses and nodules are also present. This portion contains specimens of the bryozoan genus Thamniscus, the brachiopod genus Anthracospirifer and the sclerosponges genus Chaetetes of the middle Pennsylvanian strata.
The fossil biota comes from the limestone and shale rocks of the La Joya formation, in the outcrops of La Joya that form part of the Sierra Agua Verde, which have thicknesses of approximately 294m and 780m, respectively (Ochoa-Camarillo & Sosa-León, 1993). The lower contact of the bed is contiguous with the Santiago formation, and the upper contact is formed by a normal fault with the Tuntunudé formation. The base consists of fossiliferous limestone, sandstone, mudstone, and sandstone and chert lenses. The limestone exhibits gradual stratification. At the sequence's base, it ranges from thick to massive strata with chert lenses and nodules. This portion of the sequence can be seen in the western foothills of La Joya. Next, there is a block of limestone with interbedded calcareous mudstone; the mudstone contains small quartz crystals. Present in both the limestone and the mudstone are tabulate corals and numerous plates and columns of crinoids, as well as the fragment shells of gastropods and fenestellid bryozoans. The upper part consists of limestone with interbedded calcareous mudstones, chert nodules, and lenses strata (Fig. 2).
Stratigraphic column of the La Joya formation in Sierra Agua Verde (from Ochoa-Camarillo & Sosa-León, 1993).
The biota identified in the La Joya formation contains algae of the genera Eugonophylum and Komia (Figs. 3 and 4), fusulinid foraminifera of the species Fusulinella llanoensis Thompson, 1935 (Fig. 5); Zellerella sp. (Fig. 6); Chaetetes sp. (Figs. 7-9); Syringopora sp (Fig. 10), and solitary corals such as Lophophyllidium sp., (Figs. 11-12), and fenestellid briozoans of the genus Thamniscus (Fig. 13). Brachiopods are represented by the species Reticulariina sp., (Fig. 14), Dielasma sp. (Fig. 15), Anthracospirifer sp. (Fig. 16), Antiquatonia sp., (Fig. 17). Two gastropods were identified: Straparollus (Euomphalus) sp. (Fig. 18), and Donaldina cf. D. robusta (Stevens, 1858) (Fig. 19). The crinoids are widely represented by numerous plates and columnar fragments from the species Pentagonopternix insculptus Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 20), (21) Pentaridica simplicis Moore & Jeffords, 1968 (Fig. 21); (22) Cyclocaudex sp. (Fig. 22), Mooreanteris waylandensis Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 23), Lamprosterigma mirificum Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 24), Cyclocrista martini Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 25), Preptopremnum rugosum Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 26), Preptopremnum leave Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 27), Heterostelechus keithi Moore & Jefords, 1968 (Fig. 28). Reconstruction of biotopes (Fig. 29)
(20) Pentagonopternix insculptus Moore & Jefords, 1968; (21) Pentaridica simplicis Moore & Jeffords, 1968; (22) Cyclocaudex sp.; (23) Mooreanteris waylandensis Moore & Jefords, 1968; (24) Lamprosterigma mirificum Moore & Jefords, 1968; (25) Cyclocrista martini Moore & Jefords, 1968; (26) Preptopremnum rugosum Moore & Jefords, 1968; (27) Preptopremnum leave Moore & Jefords, 1968; (28) Heterostelechus keithi Moore & Jefords, 1968.
Paleogeographic considerations of the Paleozoic central-eastern region. The Sonoran territory was located southwest of the Laurentian continent and south of the Equator during the middle-late Paleozoic era. Sedimentary facies occur in the mid-eastern region and predominantly consist of a calcareous platform with basinal siliciclastic deposits.
The limestone sequences are outcrops of rocks whose ages range from the Cambrian to the early Permian. Since the year 2000, interest in the mid-eastern region of Sonora has increased, particularly for the Sierra Agua Verde, as shown by the studies of Buitrón-Sánchez, Almazán-Vázquez, and Vachard (2004); Buitrón-Sánchez, Almazán-Vázquez, Vachard, Gómez-Espinosa, and Mendoza-Madera (2005), and Mendoza-Madera et al. (2004). The algae, fusulinids, and sponges of the Pennsylvanian strata in Sonora show an affinity with the biota of Arizona, New Mexico, Texas, and California, USA. A possible connection between Mexico and the Ural Mountains and/or the Paleo-Tethys (Ocean) has been reported previously by Buitrón-Sánchez, Vachard, Almazán-Vázquez, and Palafox-Reyes (2012), Vachard, Flores-de Dios, Buitrón-Sánchez, and Grajales-Nishimura (2000), Vachard, Flores-de Dios, Pantoja, Buitrón-Sánchez, Arellano, and Grajales-Nishimura (2000), and Vachard, Vidaurre-Lemus, Fourcade, and Requena (2000).
The regional geodynamic problem in Sonora is simplified, as the assemblages are similar between the North American Craton and the Caborca land form (González-León, 1989; Sedlock, Ortega-Gutierrez, & Speed, 1993). The North American Craton was separated from Gondwana and South America by a remnant of the Rheico Ocean, where some land was tectono-stratigraphically separated by carbonated platforms such as the Mixteco and Oaxaquia platforms while a number of basins were developed in the middle parts of Mexico (Almazán-Vázquez et al., 2007; Buitrón-Sánchez et al., 2007; Gómez-Espinosa, Vachard, Buitrón-Sánchez, Almazán-Vázquez, & Mendoza-Madera, 2008) (Fig. 30).
Paleogeographic reconstruction showing the connection between Sonora, the North American Craton (Arizona, Texas) and South American domain through different Mexican terrains (Coahuila, Maya, Mixteco, and Oaxaquia). 1, Carbonate platforms; 2, flysch basins; 3, islands and continents (Gómez-Espinosa et al., 2008).
Paleozoic marine outcrops of Mexico are rare compared to terrestrial extensions, as these formations are often covered by a thick sequence of Mesozoic and Cenozoic sediments. However, there are a number of localities where these sedimentary Carboniferous marine rocks, containing crinoid fossils of the Mississippian and Pennsylvanian, are exposed. In Mexico, these areas are found in the northern states of Sonora and Tamaulipas, in the central states of Hidalgo and Puebla, and in the southern states of Guerrero, Oaxaca, and Chiapas. The biota identified in the La Joya formation contain algae of 2 genera, Eugonophylum and Komia; fusulinid foraminifera of the species Pseudostaffella sp., E. texana, F. llanoensis, and Zellerella sp.; sclerosponges of the genus Chaetetes; tabulate corals such as Syringopora and solitary corals such as Lophophyllidium sp., and fenestellid bryozoans of the genus Thamniscus. The brachiopods are represented by the species Dielasma sp., Reticulariina sp., Anthracospirifer sp., Antiquatonia sp.; 2 genera of gastropods were also identified, Euomphalus and Donaldina. The crinoids are widely represented by numerous columns and articulated plates of the genera Pentaridica, Pentagonopternix, Cyclocaudex, Mooreanteris, Lamprosterigma, Cyclocrista, Preptopremnum, Heterosteleschus, and Cycloscapus. The exact locations of these genera can be seen in the stratigraphic column. The present study relates the age of the layers that contain the biota of the Sierra Agua Verde, Sonora, to the stratigraphic index layers of Kansas, Colorado, and Texas in the United States of America. The age of the Sonoran strata corresponds to that of the Atokan stage, the floor of the Upper Pennsylvanian strata, which is 311 million years old. The specimens of the species comprising the biota found in the outcrop deposits occurred close to the coast, as interpreted by the presence of organisms that typically inhabited the shallow, warm waters of a coastal marine environment.
This paper is a contribution of the Projects Conacyt No. 165826, UNAM DGAPA-PAPIIT No. 105012, and ECOS No. M13U01. The authors are particularly grateful to Departamento de Geología, Universidad de Sonora. This paper is dedicated to the memory of Dr. Emilio Almazán Vázquez who died in 2010, and who did much to further the knowledge of the Paleozoic geology of Sonora.
Peer Review under the responsibility of Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.