Severe asthma is found in approximately 10% of patients with asthma. Some factors associated with worse asthma control include rhinitis, gastroesophageal reflux disease, vocal cord dysfunction (VCD), nasal polyposis and bronchiectasis. Therefore, we evaluated the prevalence of these illnesses in patients with severe asthma.
METHODSWe conducted a retrospective analysis of data obtained from electronic medical records of patients with severe asthma between January 2006 and June 2008. Symptoms of rhinitis and gastroesophageal reflux disease were evaluated as well as intolerance to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. We evaluated the results of esophagogastroduodenoscopy, videolaryngoscopy and CT scans of the chest in order to confirm gastroesophageal reflux disease, nasal polyposis, vocal cord dysfunction and bronchiectasis.
RESULTSWe evaluated 245 patients. Rhinitis symptoms were present in 224 patients (91.4%); 18 (7.3%) had intolerance to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and 8 (3.3%) had nasal polyposis. Symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease were reported for 173 (70.6%) patients, although the diagnosis of gastroesophageal reflux disease was confirmed based on esophagogastroduodenoscopy or laryngoscopy findings in just 58 (33.6%) patients. Vocal cord dysfunction was suspected in 16 (6.5%) and confirmed through laryngoscopy in 4 (1.6%). The patient records provided CT scans of the chest for 105 patients, and 26 (24.8%) showed bronchiectasis.
DISCUSSIONRhinitis and gastroesophageal reflux disease were the most common comorbidities observed, in addition to bronchiectasis. Therefore, in patients with severe asthma, associated diseases should be investigated as the cause of respiratory symptoms and uncontrolled asthma.
The prevalence of asthma is increasing in most countries. The global prevalence ranges from 1 to 18%, which makes it a public health problem that has increasingly become of interest to researchers.1 Around 10% of asthma patients have severe asthma, and some of these cases are defined as difficult-to-control asthma.
Difficult-to-control severe asthma, although accounting for no more than 5% of all asthma cases, is responsible for approximately 50% of the overall costs related to asthma treatment. It is also associated with greater morbidity and mortality. The risk of requiring treatment in the emergency room and of requiring hospitalization is 15 and 20 times greater, respectively, for such patients than for those with less severe forms of asthma.2–5
In individuals with severe asthma, comorbidities are common, with the most prevalent being gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), sinusitis, allergic rhinitis and nasal polyposis. All of these can lead to worsening of the asthma symptoms.6
Allergic rhinitis and allergic asthma are currently recognized as manifestations of a single entity: chronic allergic respiratory disease, also known as “united airway disease”.7,8 The great majority of patients with asthma have rhinitis, which is itself a risk factor for the development of asthma.
Individuals with asthma often present with GERD, which has been shown to exacerbate asthma through mechanisms involving vagal nerve stimulation (esophagobronchial reflex) or microaspiration of gastric contents into the upper airways.9–11
Other diseases that are rare and sometimes difficult to diagnose, including vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) and allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis (ABPA), are also associated with worse asthma control.
The features of VCD include episodes of involuntary paradoxical movements caused by vocal cord adduction during inspiration, resulting in airway obstruction. Although VCD can be seen in patients with asthma, it can also occur in an isolated form in individuals without respiratory disease.12,13
Aspirin-induced asthma (AIA) is a clinical entity characterized by asthma and intolerance to aspirin or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs).14 AIA and nasal polyposis are associated with an increase in asthma severity.14,15
Asthma and bronchiectasis coexist in many patients, and it has been shown that bronchiectasis can contribute to severe and difficult-to-control asthma with pulmonary complications.16
In order to improve the treatment of patients with severe asthma and to control the disease, comorbidities must be taken into consideration, and it is important to treat these conditions simultaneously.
We investigated the occurrence of rhinitis, intolerance to NSAIDs, nasal polyposis, GERD, VCD and bronchiectasis in patients with severe asthma.
MATERIALS AND METHODSWe conducted a retrospective analysis of data obtained from electronic medical records between January 2006 and June 2008 for patients who met the 2008 Global Initiative for Asthma (GINA) criteria for diagnosis of severe persistent asthma.1
The patients were asked about symptoms of rhinitis, GERD and intolerance to NSAIDs. Rhinorrhea, nasal pruritus, sneezing and congestion were all considered to be symptoms consistent with rhinitis. The severity and frequency of the symptoms were defined according to the criteria established in the World Health Organization review entitled Allergic Rhinitis and Its Impact on Asthma (ARIA).7 Regurgitation, heartburn and retrosternal discomfort were considered to be suggestive of GERD. Only patients presenting specific complaints of exacerbation resulting from the use of aspirin or NSAIDs were considered to be intolerant to those medications.
A diagnosis of VCD was suspected in patients who reported worsening of symptoms or attacks in situations of emotional stress, were refractory to routine asthma treatment, presented cervical inspiratory wheezing, and had a peripheral oxygen saturation that remained above 95% even during severe attacks. Suspicion of VCD was also raised for patients in whom spirometry revealed flattening of the inspiratory loop of the flow-volume curve, which is suggestive of extrathoracic obstruction, and in those presenting a difficult-to-control clinical profile with normal or only slightly altered pulmonary function. Thus, VCD was considered when there was a discrepancy between clinical features, laboratory exams and treatment.
The study also included esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD), videolaryngoscopy and high-resolution computed tomography (CT) scans of the chest. Findings that could be consistent with GERD varied from mild to severe esophagitis, as seen under direct EGD visualization. Other clinical findings suggestive of GERD were seen under videolaryngoscopy as mild to severe posterior laryngitis. The results of endoscopic examination of the larynx were considered consistent with VCD when there was two-thirds closure of the vocal cords with a diamond-shaped opening occurring posteriorly during inspiration. The same examination was used to confirm the presence of nasal polyps. We also evaluated CT scans of the chest in order to identify bronchiectasis.
RESULTSWe evaluated 245 patients, 194 females and 51 males, all of whom were being treated with inhaled corticosteroids. Six patients (2.5%) were also receiving oral corticosteroids in an attempt to control their asthma. The mean patient age was 57.8 years, with a range of 21–85 years. Lung function tests and levels of asthma control are summarized in table 1.
Demographic data, baseline characteristics, corticosteroid treatment and lung function (all patients)
| n (female/male) | 245 (194/51) |
| Age (years), median (range) | 57.8 (21 – 85) |
| Corticosteroid treatment | |
| Under ICS treatment, n (%) | 245 (100%) |
| Under OCS treatment, n (%) | 6 (2.5%) |
| Lung function - Degree of severity# (%) | |
| Normal | 1.3 |
| Mild | 23.2 |
| Moderate | 23.2 |
| Moderately severe | 24.3 |
| Severe | 25.0 |
| Very severe | 3.0 |
| FEV1 % predicted, median (range) | 60 (32 – 99) |
| Levels of asthma control* (%) | |
| Controlled | 5.4 |
| Partly controlled | 62.3 |
| Uncontrolled | 32.3 |
ICS, inhaled corticosteroid; OCS, oral corticosteroid; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1s
Rhinitis was seen in 224 patients (91.4%), and the majority of these patients had persistent and moderate-to-severe rhinitis (Figures 1 and 2).
Severity of rhinitis symptoms among severe asthma patients (defined according to the criteria established in Allergic Rhinitis and its Impact on Asthma – ARIA7).
Frequency of rhinitis symptoms among severe asthma patients (defined according to the criteria established in Allergic Rhinitis and its Impact on Asthma – ARIA7)
Intolerance to NSAIDs or nasal polyposis was found in 21 patients (8.5%). There were 13 patients with intolerance to NSAIDs who did not have nasal polyps, and there were 3 patients with nasal polyposis who did not report intolerance to NSAIDs (Figure 3).
Symptoms of GERD were reported for 173 (70.6%) of the patients evaluated, although the diagnosis of GERD was confirmed based on the previously cited criteria in just 58 (33.6%) (Figure 4).
Among the 245 asthma patients evaluated, VCD was suspected in 16 (6.5%) and confirmed through videolaryngoscopy in 4 (1.6%).
CT scans of the chest were taken for 105 patients, of whom 26 (24.8%) showed bronchiectasis.
DISCUSSIONAlthough only 10% of asthma cases are classified as severe, such cases are responsible for greater morbidity and mortality. In addition, other factors and comorbidities such as GERD, rhinosinusitis and VCD contribute to poor asthma control, although the exact impact these factors have on the severity of the disease has not been well established.6
The prevalence of rhinitis among patients with asthma is around 75 to 80%.7 Various studies have demonstrated that among atopic diseases, asthma and rhinitis are the ones most often seen in combination. In addition, allergic rhinitis is considered a major risk factor for the development of asthma, as has been well documented in various countries, including Brazil, in the International Study of Asthma and Allergy in Childhood.18,19 The prevalence of rhinitis in the patients with severe asthma evaluated in the present study, however, was higher than that reported in the majority of studies found in the literature. We believe that the high prevalence in our study can be attributed to the fact that our patient population had severe asthma.7 Some studies have demonstrated that the presence of severe rhinitis in a patient with asthma is associated with a less favorable outcome. It is also possible that the presence of more than one allergic respiratory disease will lead to an allergy specialist referral. In addition, it has been shown that the treatment of nasal symptoms can be beneficial to the lower respiratory tract, reducing the number of emergency room visits and hospitalizations and limiting bronchial hyperresponsiveness.19,20
Although hypersensitivity to NSAIDs and aspirin affects only 0.6–2.5% of the general population of adults, it occurs in 5–20% of adults with asthma.21 In our sample, only 3.2% of the patients reported asthma exacerbation after the use of NSAIDs; however, this finding might indicate that many patients are not able to perceive such exacerbation, as has previously been demonstrated. In a study conducted in Europe involving 500 patients diagnosed with aspirin-intolerant asthma, 90 (18%) were unable to perceive worsening symptoms prior to the provocation test.21 In the present study, only the clinical profile of NSAID-induced bronchospasm was considered. None of the patients underwent a challenge test.
Asthma and GERD frequently coexist.22 Concomitance between symptoms of dyspnea and reflux is quite common, and large-scale studies have shown that the degree of reflux can be as much as 60% greater in those with asthma as compared to individuals without asthma.23 In a study conducted in the United Kingdom, the prevalence of GERD symptoms among patients with difficult-to-control asthma was found to be 75%, which is comparable to the findings in our sample.24 In the same study, however, 24-h pH-metry revealed the true prevalence to be only 55%. In the present study, the patients were submitted to EGD and videolaryngoscopy, through which 58 patients (23.6%) were diagnosed with concomitant asthma and GERD. Not all of our patients, however, underwent these tests.
Despite the fact that VCD has been increasingly studied, its prevalence has yet to be well defined. In Brazil, the reported prevalence of VCD is around 17.5% among patients with severe asthma.12 In our study, the patient charts indicated that VCD was suspected in only 6.5% of cases. We believe that VCD is under-diagnosed, however, since the diagnosis was confirmed in more than 16 patients at our outpatient clinic.25,26
It is common to see abnormal CT scan results in those with asthma, as previously reported by several authors. In addition to abnormalities such as hyperinflation, mucoid impaction, acinar pattern, lobar collapse and bronchial wall thickening, which are expected in patients with asthma, other less common findings such as bronchiectasis are increasing in frequency. The reported incidence of bronchiectasis among asthma patients is between 37% and 65%. The use of CT for the diagnosis of bronchiectasis has been validated in various studies in which the patients were submitted to CT and bronchogram.27
Autopsy studies have shown that 15–20% of patients who died from exacerbation of asthma had bronchiectasis, most often in the upper lobes. One hypothesis to explain the prevalence of bronchial dilation in asthma patients is destruction of the bronchi by an inflammatory process or recurrent infection. In our study, 24.8% of 105 patients who underwent CT showed bronchiectasis. Some of these patients could have also had ABPA, which is difficult to diagnose. It has been reported that the majority of patients do not meet all of the diagnostic criteria simultaneously, and many such patients are receiving corticosteroid therapy, which can mask the symptoms.27
CONCLUSIONSRhinitis and GERD were the most common comorbidities observed, in addition to bronchiectasis. Therefore, in patients with severe asthma, associated diseases should be investigated as the cause of respiratory symptoms and uncontrolled asthma.