Vocal cord paralysis is a rare but severe complication after orotracheal intubation. The most common cause is traumatic, due to compression of the recurrent laryngeal nerve between the orotracheal tube cuff and the thyroid cartilage. Other possible causes are direct damage to the vocal cords during intubation, dislocation of the arytenoid cartilages, or infections, especially viral infections. It is usually due to a recurrent laryngeal nerve neuropraxia, and the course is benign in most patients. We present the case of a man who developed late bilateral vocal cord paralysis after pneumonia complicated with respiratory distress due to SARS-CoV-2 that required orotracheal intubation for 11 days. He presented symptoms of dyspnea 20 days after discharge from hospital with subsequent development of stridor, requiring a tracheostomy. Due to the temporal evolution, a possible contribution of the SARS-CoV-2 infection to the picture is pointed out.
La parálisis de cuerdas vocales es una complicación poco frecuente, aunque severa, tras una intubación orotraqueal. La causa más frecuente es la traumática, debido a la compresión del nervio laríngeo recurrente entre el maguito del tubo orotraqueal y el cartílago tiroides. Otras posibles causas son lesión directa de las cuerdas vocales durante la intubación, luxación de los cartílagos aritenoides e infecciones, sobre todo víricas. Suele deberse a una neuroapraxia del nervio laríngeo recurrente, y el curso es benigno en la mayoría de los pacientes. Presentamos el caso de un varón que desarrolló una parálisis de cuerdas vocales bilateral tras una neumonía complicada con distrés respiratorio por SARS-CoV-2 que requirió intubación orotraqueal durante 11 días. Presentó clínica de disnea a los 20 días del alta hospitalaria con desarrollo posterior de estridor, siendo necesaria la realización de una traqueostomía. Debido a la evoución temporal, se apunta una posible contribución de la infección por SARS-CoV-2 al cuadro.
Bilateral vocal cord palsy is a rare but serious complication after tracheal intubation (TI)1. Vocal cord palsy is usually due to injury2, although in the context of viral disease it can be caused by viral neurotropism3.
SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus disease is characterized by severe pneumonia that may require prolonged mechanical ventilation, and the virus can also affect the nervous system4,5. We report the case of a patient who developed late bilateral vocal cord palsy that was diagnosed after receiving mechanical ventilation for SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia.
Case reportThe patient was a 74-year-old man with a personal history of cholecystectomy and prostatectomy, who had no previous respiratory symptoms. He developed symptoms of fever, cough and myalgia, and was diagnosed with COVID-19 infection by polymerase-transcriptase chain reaction (PCR) on a nasopharyngeal swab, and initially received outpatient treatment. Eight days after diagnosis, he was admitted to the hospital due to progressive dyspnoea. Physical examination on admission revealed tachypnoea with 24 rpm and hypoxaemia (peripheral oxygen saturation [SpO2] 85%). The chest X-ray revealed bilateral pneumonia, and blood tests revealed lymphopaenia with 0.54 × 109/L lymphocytes, D-dimers 648 ng/mL, interleukin-6 53.7 pg/mL and C-reactive protein (CRP) 7.66 mg/dL. Tests for pneumococcal antigenuria and Legionella were negative.
The patient remained on the ward for 7 days, receiving treatment with lopinavir/ritonavir, hydroxychloroquine, ceftriaxone, and azithromycin. Due to a lack of clinical improvement and worsening of inflammatory markers, 3 doses of tocilizumab were added on the third day of admission. The patient’s condition progressed to dyspnoea at rest, with bilateral crackles and PaO2/FiO2 ratio of 145, so he was admitted to the Resuscitation Unit for pneumonia complicated by respiratory distress (ARDS).
On admission, the patient presented tachypnea 32 rpm, hypoxaemia and significant work of breathing. He was intubated with a number 8 tracheal tube (TT) and was connected to mechanical ventilation, adding 1 mg/kg IV methylprednisolone to his existing regimen. Labs showed elevated acute phase reactants (ferritin 4163 ng/mL, LDH 971 IU/L, D-dimers 8714 ng/mL) and chest X-ray showed worsening of bilateral pulmonary infiltrates.
He required vasoactive support with low-dose norepinephrine (<0.1 mcg/kg/min) for the first 24 h, and received 4 cycles of prone positioning until his supine PaO2/FiO2 ratio was greater than 300 mmHg. An additional complication was worsening of renal function in the first 24 h (peak creatinine of 1.75 mg/dL) that improved with fluid intake and furosemide. The TT became obstructed with mucous on the sixth day of admission and was changed. After extubation, 11 days after admission to the unit, he developed acute confusional syndrome that required treatment with quetiapine and resolved within 24 h.
He remained in the unit for 13 days, and 2 negative COVID PCR tests were obtained from bronchial secretions prior to transfer to the ward. He remained on the ward for a further week, with dyspnoea or respiratory distress, and was in good general condition on discharge from hospital: baseline SpO2 98% and basal hypoventilation with no adventitious sounds on auscultation.
During telephone follow-up to his home he reported good evolution, being able to lead an active life and walk several kilometres each day. Twenty days after hospital discharge, he developed progressive nocturnal cough, dyspnoea, and supine breath sounds that improved when standing. He went to the Emergency Department and was evaluated by a pulmonologist, who ruled out lung involvement. Bronchodilator treatment was started, but due to the persistence of the condition, he was assessed by the ENT specialist on day 35 after discharge, at which point the patient had already developed stridor. A fibreoptic endoscopy study revealed bilateral palsy of the vocal cords in the medial position, and head neck and chest computerized tomography was unremarkable. Given the progression of the symptoms of dyspnoea and stridor, the patient was admitted to hospital and a tracheotomy was scheduled. Before performing the tracheotomy, the patient tested positive again for SARS-CoV-2 on PCR. The serology study showed IgM negative and IgG positive for COVID-19, cytomegalovirus, Epstein Bar virus, herpes simplex virus, and varicella zoster virus, as well as a negative PCR for HIV. A new PCR for SARS-CoV-2 performed 2 days later was negative. The patient was discharged with a tracheostomy tube 4 days after admission.
DiscussionTI is a very common, usually safe procedure in critically ill patients. However, it is not entirely free from complications, some of which, such as vocal cord palsy, can be serious. This rare complication occurs in 1 in every 1500 intubations (0.07%)1, and although complications are more frequent after prolonged intubation, vocal cord injuries can also occur after short periods6. Risk factors for vocal cord palsy include age over 50 years, diabetes mellitus, and high blood pressure, together with intubation lasting more than 6 h1,6.
Various mechanisms can be involved in vocal cord palsy secondary to TI. The most widely accepted cause is compression of the inferior or recurrent laryngeal nerve between the cuff of the TT and the posterior thyroid cartilage2,7. The recurrent laryngeal nerve divides into 2 branches at the level of the cricoid cartilage. The posterior branch, which innervates the cricoarytenoid and interarytenoid muscles, does not come into contact with cuff of the tube. The anterior branch, however, which innervates most of the vocal cord abductor muscles, can be compressed between the cuff of the TT and the thyroid cartilage lamina, causing medial or paramedian vocal cord paralysis7,8. This results in hoarseness and/or respiratory stridor, unlike bilateral palsy of the recurrent nerve, which causes airway obstruction. Vocal cord palsy is usually unilateral, and 70% of injuries affect the left cord, probably because the TT is taped to the right corner of the mouth1,6.
Other mechanisms described are direct injury to the vocal cords during intubation, particularly traumatic intubation, or dislocation of the arytenoid cartilage3. The recurrent laryngeal nerve can also become elongated when the neck is hyperextended during intubation, or can be injured as a result of TT movement through the cords during ventilation3,8. Measures that can prevent this complication include choosing an appropriately sized TT, performing atraumatic TI, monitoring TT cuff pressure, and monitoring for possible malposition of airway devices9. In our case, the TT was correctly sized for the patient, both the initial intubation and the orotracheal tube change were non-traumatic, cuff pressure was monitored regularly, and prone positioning, carried out in accordance with the Unit’s protocol, was uneventful. Despite these precautions, any of these events could potentially have contributed to the patient’s condition.
The time of onset of symptoms — 30 days after extubation, ruled out mechanical compression as the injury mechanism. In unilateral vocal cord palsy, symptoms (dysphonia, hoarseness) usually appear within 24 h of extubation, and the diagnosis is usually made 2 weeks later, with a range of between 1–30 days1. The symptoms of bilateral palsy, as reported here, usually occur between 30 min and 36 h after extubation8. The late onset of symptoms also made it necessary to rule out the presence of a new tumour or abscess secondary to pneumonia, and we therefore performed a head chest and neck CT scan, which was unremarkable.
When vocal cord involvement is secondary to upper airway tract infection, the symptoms of cough, dysphonia, vocal fatigue, odynophagia and/or vocal cord palsy appear late, within a median of 22 weeks10. Infection, particularly viral infection, should also be considered as another possible injury mechanism, as case reports of vocal cord palsy in non-intubated patients have also been published3. Viral serology was performed to rule out this hypothesis, and showed no recent infection by the most common viruses.
Coronaviruses are also neurotropic, and given the similarly of different coronaviruses, it is likely that SARS-CoV-2 can induce neural lesions11, and patients such as ours, with severe infection leading to severe pneumonia, are more likely to develop neurological symptoms4,11. Two main pathways have been proposed for the entry of neurotropic respiratory viruses into the CNS: the hematogenous route (across the blood–brain barrier) and the neuronal retrograde route from peripheral nerves5. The latter is believed to be responsible for the appearance of anosmia and ageusia in more than 5% of SARS-CoV-2 patients11. For this reason, we included possible reactivation of the coronavirus in our diagnostic options, since cases of viral reactivation after hospital discharge have been published12, and the patient presented a positive PCR at the time of vocal cord palsy diagnosis. However, the serology study reported negative IgM and positive IgG for SARS-CoV-2, and 2 further PCR tests (one after tracheostomy and the other a few days later) were negative, so the patient was diagnosed with non-active COVID, and the positive PCR before the tracheostomy was attributed to the presence of viral fragment in the upper airway with no infectious potential.
Post-TI vocal cord plasy is usually benign, and 68.4% of patients make a full recovery7. As it is usually due to neuropraxia of the recurrent laryngeal nerve, functional recovery is rapid8. In the case reported here, the vocal cord palsy persisted at the 3-month follow-up, although the patient is now able to talk and swallow.
In conculsion, we present a case of bilateral vocal cord palsy after tracheal intubation in a patient who developed pneumonia complicated by ARDS due to SARS-CoV-2. After ruling out the presence of a tumour or compressive infectious complications, viral reactivation or reinfection, the most likely mechanism was nerve compression during intubation, although we were unable to rule out a neurological complication associated with coronavirus infection, a disease that is not yet fully understood. Bilateral vocal cord palsy secondary to TI, though rare, should be taken into consideration if symptoms such as dyspnoea or stridor appear after extubation, even though these can be a late development, as was the case in our patient.
Conflict of interestsThe authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
Please cite this article as: Curros Mata N, Alvarado de la Torre S, Carballo Fernández J, Martínez Morán A, Álvarez Refojo F, Rama-Maceiras P. Parálisis bilateral tardía de cuerdas vocales trasintubación endotraqueal por neumonía COVID-19. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim. 2022;69:105–108.
