metricas
covid
Buscar en
Clinics
Toda la web
Inicio Clinics Why ophthalmology? Analysis of the motivating factors influencing the choice of ...
Información de la revista
Vol. 74.
(enero 2019)
Compartir
Compartir
Descargar PDF
Más opciones de artículo
Visitas
1847
Vol. 74.
(enero 2019)
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Open Access
Why ophthalmology? Analysis of the motivating factors influencing the choice of ophthalmology as a career among different generations in Brazil
Visitas
1847
Gustavo Rosa GameiroI,
Autor para correspondencia
gustavo.gameiro@fm.usp.br

Corresponding author.
, Ana Letícia Fornazieri DarcieII, Daniel HazakiII, Giovana Rosa GameiroIII, Pedro Carlos CarricondoII
I Faculdade de Medicina FMUSP, Universidade de Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, SP, BR
II Departamento de Oftalmologia, Hospital das Clinicas HCFMUSP, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade de Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, SP, BR
III Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade Estadual de Londrina, Londrina, PR, BR
Este artículo ha recibido

Under a Creative Commons license
Información del artículo
Resumen
Texto completo
Bibliografía
Descargar PDF
Estadísticas
Figuras (4)
Mostrar másMostrar menos
OBJECTIVES:

The increasing demand for medical specialties with flexible working hours has been associated with the important role of quality of life as a determining factor when choosing a career in medicine, which might change the motivations for pursuing a career in ophthalmology. We aim to identify the main determinants of ophthalmology as a career choice as well as the reasons that motivated previous generations to follow this path.

METHODS:

Responses to self-administered online questionnaires were analyzed.

RESULTS:

A total of 225 responses were analyzed, including those of baby boomers (21), generation X (48), generation Y (131) and generation Z (25). Although the main reasons for choosing ophthalmology as a career are the same for all the generations in this study (flexible working hours, self-satisfaction from helping people improve their vision and the possibility of performing surgical procedures), some reasons for this career choice are more important to the younger generations (short-term results and short procedures), and some are more important to the older generations (the influence of an ophthalmologist in the family).

CONCLUSION:

The main reasons for choosing ophthalmology as a career are essentially the same over time. The differences in secondary motivations could be explained by generational differences.

Palabras clave:
Ophthalmology
Career Choice
Career Satisfaction
Motivation
Choice Behavior
Texto completo
INTRODUCTION

In recent years, the search for professional areas with flexible working hours by new graduate physicians has attracted the attention of scholars worldwide, showing a shift in the profile of new physicians. A growing demand for positions in ophthalmology, dermatology, otorhinolaryngology, psychiatry and radiology has been reported 1–4.

The main motivations for choosing a medical specialty include the intellectual challenge, market perspectives and, recently, quality of life 5–9. The high importance given to work-life balance when choosing a medical career has been noted as being responsible for the increasing demand for certain specialties over other, more traditional areas such as internal medicine, pediatrics and general surgery 5–8,10–18.

Changes in motivation can be explained by generational differences, as members of each generation have their own attitudes, preferences and key characteristics. In spite of better dealing with differences and working better in a group, the current generation of medical students and residents, known as generation Y or millennials, is often described as being immediatist, desiring change, being individualistic and advocating for quality of life and leisure time 19–23. Their particular traits could influence their main motivations in their career choices.

Many studies have investigated the current reasons for choosing different medical specialties; however, only a few have focused on understanding the selection of less traditional specialties and the differences among generations. This study aims to characterize the main current determinants of the choice of ophthalmology as a specialty as well as the reasons that influenced previous generations to pursue this career.

METHODSParticipants

The sample was composed of Brazilian medical students participating in ophthalmology interest groups, ophthalmology residents in institutions accredited by the Brazilian Council of Ophthalmology and ophthalmologists in private practice. One thousand two hundred fifty-three subjects were contacted by email to answer a self-administered online questionnaire. Acceptance of the electronic consent form was necessary before proceeding to the questionnaire itself.

The participants were divided into generational groups according to their birth year (baby boomers: 1946-1964; generation X: 1965-1980; generation Y/millennials: 1981-1994; and generation Z: 1995-).

Instruments

The instrument used in this study was an online self-administered questionnaire with objective questions regarding demographic information, reasons for choosing ophthalmology as a specialty, the presence of ophthalmologists in the family and the time of selection of the specialty. The questionnaire was sent via email by the Brazilian Council of Ophthalmology and the Brazilian Association of Ophthalmology Interest Groups.

A sample of the administered questionnaire is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1.

Questionnaire.

(0.36MB).
Data Analysis

Data analysis was performed with the aid of the computer program SPSS v.24.0 (IBM, Armonk, New York) using the appropriate tests for each variable, which are displayed after each table.

Ethical Approval

Ethical approval for this study was obtained from the Research Ethics Committees (Comitês de Ética em Pesquisa - CEP) under protocol 2.622.328/2018.

RESULTS

The response rate was 17.95%. A total of 225 responses were analyzed, which consisted of the responses from the baby boomers (n=21), generation X (n=48), generation Y (n=131) and generation Z (n=25) groups, as shown in Table 1. The participants included 114 ophthalmologists, 51 ophthalmology residents and 60 medical students (Table 1). There were no significant differences in the gender composition of the groups (Table 1).

Table 1.

Demographic analysis of the participants.

Generation  Frequency  Percentage 
Baby boomer  21  9.3 
Generation X  48  21.3 
Generation Y  131  58.2 
Generation Z  25  11.1 
Total  225  100 
Level of training  Frequency  Percentage 
Ophthalmologist  114  50.7 
Ophthalmology resident  51  22.7 
Medical student  60  26.7 
Total  225  100 
Gender  Frequency  Percentage 
Male  121  53.8 
Female  104  46.2 
Total  225  100 
Region  Frequency  Percentage 
North  4.0 
Midwest  19  8.4 
Northeast  27  12.0 
Southeast  145  64.4 
South  25  11.1 
Total  225  100 
Ophthalmologist in the family  Frequency  Percentage 
No  159  70.7 
Yes  66  29.3 
Total  225  100 

The majority of the participants were from the Southeast Region (64%), followed by the Northeast Region (12%) and South Region (11%), as shown in Table 1.

When asked about having an ophthalmologist in the family, 70.7% of the participants in our study answered negatively (Table 1).

The main motivations behind each generation's choice of a career in ophthalmology as well as the significant differences among them are shown in Table 2.

Table 2.

Main reasons for choosing a career in ophthalmology.

Reason  Baby boomer  Generation X  Generation Y  Generation Z  All  p-value 
Surgical procedures  52%  65%  70%  64%  67%  0.415a 
Flexible working hours  48%  48%  58%  48%  54%  0.519a 
Personal satisfaction from helping people improve their vision  52%  40%  37%  44%  40%  0.598a 
Compensation  24%  23%  38%  28%  32%  0.180a 
Short-term results  14%  17%  34%  20%  27%  0.049*a 
Influence of another person (mentor, professor, role model)  43%  29%  22%  20%  25%  0.182a 
Technological innovations  29%  31%  24%  16%  25%  0.502a 
Little contact with emergency situations  24%  19%  27%  20%  24%  0.622a 
Short procedures  5%  6%  34%  24%  24%  0.000*a 
Exposure to the area during medical school  19%  38%  19%  24%  24%  0.076a 
Interface with other areas of medicine  29%  15%  16%  48%  20%  0.002*a 
Personal experience of an ophthalmic condition  14%  31%  16%  16%  19%  0.144b 
Influence of an ophthalmologist in the family  33%  19%  12%  36%  18%  0.008*b 
Characteristics of the residency program  0%  6%  24%  16%  17%  0.002*b 
More individualized work  19%  15%  16%  12%  16%  0.944b 
Extracurricular experiences in the area  5%  21%  13%  20%  15%  0.260b 
Academic career  0%  8%  10%  28%  11%  0.022*b 
Intellectual challenge  5%  10%  6%  4%  7%  0.749b 
Altruism  0%  4%  3%  8%  4%  0.479b 
Social recognition  5%  0%  3%  0%  2%  0.483b 
a

-chi-square,

b

- Fisher's Exact test,

*

- statistically significant.

The majority of the participants chose to follow ophthalmology as a career after being exposed to the area during medical school (77.7%), except for those who had a relative who was an ophthalmologist, who chose the career earlier, as seen in Table 3.

Table 3.

Time of career choice.

Chi-square = 0.003  No ophthalmologist in the family  Ophthalmologist in the family  Total 
Before being exposed to ophthalmology  27  23  50 
After being exposed to ophthalmology  132  43  175 
Total  159  66  225 
DISCUSSIONOld but still gold

In our study, we tried to identify whether younger generations aiming for a career in ophthalmology are influenced by different reasons than older generations in making their career choices, following the current trend of deciding on lifestyle-friendly residency programs 2–3.

According to previous studies 9,24–27, the main reasons for choosing ophthalmology as a career are the possibility of performing surgical procedures, flexibility, earning potential and intellectual stimulation.

The strongest determining factors of career choices for all generation groups in this study were in accordance with the previous results in the literature, and there were no significant differences among the groups, showing that the main reasons for choosing ophthalmology may be essentially consistent over time (Figure 2).

Figure 2.

Percentage of the participants in each generation that indicated the possibility of surgical procedures and flexible working hours as important reasons for choosing a residency in ophthalmology. No significant differences were found among the groups (p-values of 0.415 and 0.519, respectively).

(0.08MB).
All things come to those who… want?

Although the main reasons for choosing a career in ophthalmology were the same for all groups, some reasons were significantly more important to the generation Y and generation Z physicians. This motivational trend can be explained by differences among generations.

Known for their impatience and immediatism, generation Y craves instant gratification, which may reflect the motivations that influence their career choices. In fact, direct access (no requirement to first complete an internal medicine residency) to ophthalmology residency programs and short-term results were significantly (p=0.002 and p=0.047) more important to the younger generations than to the older generations. Additionally, the short length of ophthalmic surgical procedures was statistically more likely to be identified by the generation Y and Z participants than by the participants from previous generations (p=0.000) (Figure 3).

Figure 3.

Percentage of the participants in each generation that chose short-term results, short procedures and the characteristics of the residency program (direct access) as important reasons for choosing ophthalmology. Generations Y and Z valued these reasons significantly more than the previous generations (p-values of 0.049, less than 0.0001 and 0.002, respectively).

(0.09MB).
The apple does not fall far from the tree

The influence of an ophthalmologist in the family was noted as a determinant for the choice of ophthalmology by 33.3% of the baby boomers, 18.8% of the generation X participants, 12.2% of the millennials and 36% of the generation Z participants, with statistically significant differences among the groups (p-value of 0.008) (Figure 4).

Figure 4.

Percentage of the participants in each generation that indicated the influence of an ophthalmologist in the family as an important factor for choosing a career in ophthalmology. Generation Z participants and baby boomers were the most impacted by this circumstance, with 36% and 33% of the participants answering positively, respectively (p-value of 0.008).

(0.07MB).

Although having an ophthalmologist relative was not one of the most cited reasons, 34.8% of the participants who had an ophthalmologist in the family chose a career in ophthalmology before being exposed to the area during medical school; this finding differed from that for the other participants without an ophthalmologist in the family, as 83% of these participants had decided on a career in ophthalmology during the last years of their graduate studies (p-value of 0.003) (Table 3).

Last and least

The least cited reasons among all generation groups for choosing ophthalmology as a career were altruism, the intellectual challenge and social recognition. This finding is inconsistent with the main determinants of the choice of medicine as a career that have been traditionally described in the literature 28–31. Whether future ophthalmologists will choose to attend medical school for different reasons remains to be investigated.

Pursuing an academic career was an important motivator for 28% of the generation Z participants and for 11% of the respondents overall (p=0.022). This result might arise from a selection bias since, at the time of the study, most of the participants in the generation Z group were involved in academic research activities linked to their participation in ophthalmology interest groups, which are organizations run by medical students interested in ophthalmology who organize and participate in extracurricular activities related to the field.

CONCLUSIONS

The main reasons for choosing ophthalmology as a career differ from the determinants for deciding to be a physician. Whether a change in motivation occurs during medical school for those who decide on the ophthalmology career path remains to be investigated.

The differences in the motivations for deciding to become an ophthalmologist could be explained by generational differences. The immediatism of members of younger generations may impact their career choice determinants so that not only quality of life but also short-term results are highly valued. However, the main reasons for choosing ophthalmology are essentially consistent over time.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

Gameiro GR, Darcie ALF and Hazaki D contributed to the conception and design of the manuscript, literature review, manuscript drafting, critical revision and final approval of the version to be published. Gameiro RG contributed to the drafting of the final version of the manuscript, critical revision and final approval of the version to be published. Carricondo PC contributed to the conception and design of the manuscript, critical revision of the manuscript and final approval of the version to be published.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We thank the Brazilian Council of Ophthalmology and the Brazilian Association of Ophthalmology Leagues for sending our questionnaire via email and thus helping us with this research.

REFERENCES
[1]
HG Gough .
Specialty preferences of physicians and medical students.
J Med Educ, 50 (1975), pp. 581-588
[2]
RW Schwartz , RK Jarecky , WE Strodel , JV Haley , B Young , WO Griffen Jr .
Controllable lifestyle: a new factor in career choice by medical students.
[3]
DS Lind , JC Cendan .
Two decades of student career choice at the University of Florida: increasingly a lifestyle decision.
Am Surg, 69 (2003), pp. 53-55
[4]
I Kolcić , O Polasek , H Mihalj , E Gombac , V Kraljević , I Kraljević , et al.
Research involvement, specialty choice, and emigration preferences of final year medical students in Croatia.
Croat Med J, 46 (2005), pp. 88-95
[5]
TA Lieu , SA Schroeder , DF Altman .
Specialty choices at one medical school: recent trends and analysis of predictive factors.
[6]
JH Burack , DM Irby , JD Carline , DM Ambrozy , KE Ellsbury , FT Stritter .
A study of medical students’ specialty-choice pathways: trying on possible selves.
[7]
MR Alves , AF Naskashima .
Motivações e percepções de médicos residentes em relação è escolha da carreira em Oftalmologia.
Rev Bras Oftalmol, 62 (2003), pp. 776-781
[8]
L Correia Lima de Souza , VR Mendonça , GB Garcia , EC Brandão , M Barral-Netto .
Medical Specialty Choice and Related Factors of Brazilian Medical Students and Recent Doctors.
[9]
A Uemoto , R Kawamoto , M Abe , T Kusunoki , K Kohara , T Miki .
The differences in speciality preferences and career determinant factors between first- and fifth-year medical school students.
[10]
JG Marschall , AA Karimuddin .
Decline in popularity of general surgery as a career choice in North America: review of postgraduate residency training selection in Canada, 1996-2001.
[11]
ER Dorsey , D Jarjoura , GW Rutecki .
The influence of controllable lifestyle and sex on the specialty choices of graduating U.S. medical students, 1996-2003.
[12]
PA Creed , J Searle , ME Rogers .
Medical specialty prestige and lifestyle preferences for medical students.
[13]
S Parsa , A Aghazadeh , AA Nejatisafa , H Amini , MR Mohammadi , B Mostafazadeh , et al.
Freshmen versus interns’ specialty interests.
Arch Iran Med, 13 (2010), pp. 509-515
[14]
Y Takeda , K Morio , L Snell , J Otaki , M Takahashi , I Kai .
Characteristic profiles among students and junior doctors with specific career preferences.
[15]
RW Schwartz , JV Haley , C Williams , RK Jarecky , WE Strodel , B Young , et al.
The controllable lifestyle factor and students’ attitudes about specialty selection.
[16]
DA Newton , MS Grayson , LF Thompson .
The variable influence of lifestyle and income on medical students’ career specialty choices: data from two U.S. medical schools, 1998-2004.
[17]
K Tardiff , D Cella , C Seiferth , S Perry .
Selection and change of specialties by medical school graduates.
J Med Educ, 61 (1986), pp. 790-796
[18]
L Enoch , JT Chibnall , DL Schindler , SJ Slavin .
Association of medical student burnout with residency specialty choice.
[19]
NJ Borges , RS Manuel , CL Elam , BJ Jones .
Comparing millennial and generation X medical students at one medical school.
[20]
ME Olson .
The “Millennials”: first year in practice.
[21]
JM Twenge .
Generational changes and their impact in the classroom: teaching Generation Me.
[22]
C DiLullo , P McGee , RM Kriebel .
Demystifying the Millennial student: a reassessment in measures of character and engagement in professional education.
[23]
SK Pingleton .
Millennial health care: change you can believe in.
[24]
J Noble .
Factors influencing career choice in ophthalmology.
[25]
J Noble , S Schendel , S Daniel , MO Baerlocher .
Motivations and future trends: a survey of Canadian ophthalmology residents.
[26]
M Abdulrahman , M Makki , S Shaaban , M Al Shamsi , M Venkatramana , N Sulaiman , et al.
Specialty preferences and motivating factors: A national survey on medical students from five uae medical schools.
Educ Health, 29 (2016), pp. 231-243
[27]
TW Lambert , MJ Goldacre , AJ Bron .
Career choices for ophthalmology made by newly qualified doctors in the United Kingdom, 1974-2005.
[28]
IC McManus , G Livingston , C Katona .
The attractions of medicine: the generic motivations of medical school applicants in relation to demography, personality and achievement.
[29]
LR Millan , RS Azevedo , E Rossi , OL De Marco , MP Millan , PC de Arruda .
What is behind a student’s choice for becoming a doctor?.
[30]
NE Wagoner , SD Bridwell .
High school students’ motivations for a career as a physician.
[31]
R Kleinert , C Fuchs , V Romotzky , L Knepper , ML Wasilewski , W Schröder , et al.
Generation Y and surgical residency - Passing the baton or the end of the world as we know it? Results from a survey among medical students in Germany.

No potential conflict of interest was reported.

Copyright © 2019. CLINICS
Descargar PDF
Opciones de artículo
es en pt

¿Es usted profesional sanitario apto para prescribir o dispensar medicamentos?

Are you a health professional able to prescribe or dispense drugs?

Você é um profissional de saúde habilitado a prescrever ou dispensar medicamentos